ADHD or not? Why diagnosis needs several perspectives
ADHD, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, is talked about a lot, especially on social media. But we rarely realise how complex its diagnosis is. In this talk, I give a few pointers on what ADHD is, on what can look like it, and on what a thorough assessment should include.
Talk in English, with French subtitles · 15 min · Watch on YouTube
What is ADHD?
ADHD is a neurodevelopmental disorder that makes it hard to regulate attention and executive functions. It can affect almost every area of life: emotions, behaviour, relationships, self-esteem, studies or work.
Concentration problems don’t necessarily mean ADHD
Attention difficulties are found in almost every mental health condition: depression, anxiety, bipolar disorder, addictions, OCD, post-traumatic stress… Many patients arrive convinced they have ADHD after seeing a list of criteria online: “I lose my keys”, “I forget what I came in for”. That is confusing an everyday difficulty with a diagnosis.
ADHD or anxiety?
Anxiety and depression are among the conditions that most often mimic ADHD. The difference: with ADHD, it isn’t that you can’t concentrate, it’s that you struggle to regulate your concentration. A child with ADHD can stay hyperfocused for hours on what motivates them, and drift off within two minutes on everything else. With anxiety or depression, the difficulty is more general. Anxiety is also very often associated with ADHD: the two then need to be untangled, the anxiety treated first, and the treatment chosen with care.
Giftedness or ADHD?
A gifted child who isn’t stimulated enough can look like a child with ADHD: fidgeting, doing something else, looking elsewhere. One clue: the difficulties appear mainly at school, whereas at home the child can choose what interests them.
Two complementary approaches
The diagnostic approach answers the question “What is going on?” The functional approach answers “How does it affect this person?” A neuropsychological assessment looks at both. An IQ test, for example, isn’t about getting a number, but about seeing the child’s strengths and weaknesses. ADHD is a broad spectrum: it can mainly affect attention, mainly hyperactivity and impulsivity, or both, with different consequences.
A diagnosis of exclusion
In the reference manual, the DSM-5, ADHD is a diagnosis of exclusion: we first check that nothing else explains the symptoms. So we ask many questions about trauma, bullying, a difficult childhood, significant stress during pregnancy, and about family history, since ADHD has a strong genetic component. Early trauma increases the risk of ADHD, but post-traumatic stress also creates attention difficulties. Sometimes it is impossible to decide, and we have to accept that reality is complex.
What a good assessment should include
- A complete medical and personal history, over several appointments, as patients open up more once trust is established.
- A full assessment of abilities: IQ, attention, executive functions such as the ability to plan or to hold back an impulsive action.
- Screening for associated conditions: depression, anxiety, oppositional defiant disorder, present in about half of children with ADHD, or conduct disorder.
- An in-depth discussion with the patient and parents about the DSM-5 criteria: how many symptoms today, and how many before age 12.
- The medical expertise of a child psychiatrist.
A complex mind, a complex team
Leaving the diagnosis to a single professional increases the risk of error. ADHD is a highly clinical diagnosis, and meta-analyses show it is sometimes made wrongly. The more trained professionals see the child, talk to each other and supervise one another, the more accurate the diagnosis, and the better the care.
Wondering about this for yourself or your child? A neuropsychological assessment can help you see clearly.
Request an assessment